Looking for the perfect engagement ring in Colorado? You're in luck! This guide explores some of the best local jewelers in Colorado, each renowned for their unique designs, ethical practices, and exceptional craftsmanship.

Whether you're drawn to rustic elegance, contemporary styles, or sustainable materials, these local Colorado jewelers have something special to offer. From family-owned businesses with a legacy of excellence to boutique shops known for their personalized service, you'll discover the ideal ring that tells your unique love story.

For more information on how to propose, check out this guide on how to propose to your partner!

Young in the Mountains

Young in the Mountains, founded by jewelry designer Mariele Ivy, draws inspiration from the natural beauty of the Rockies. Mariele's journey began in Montana, where her love for the mountains and nature took root. Each piece is handcrafted using sustainable and recycled materials, making her designs not only beautiful but also eco-friendly.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Nature-Inspired Designs: Discover unique jewelry pieces in Denver that reflect the natural beauty of Colorado.

• Ethical Materials: Committed to using sustainable and recycled materials, ensuring your jewelry is as eco-friendly as it is beautiful.

• Personal Connection: Each custom piece tells a unique story and is crafted with love and attention to detail.

Website: Young in the Mountains

Back to Top

Balefire Goods

Balefire Goods, a woman-owned store founded by Jamie Hollier, is a hub for contemporary, edgy jewelry. Jamie started the store with a passion for supporting artisans and creating unique, wearable art. They create custom pieces and also stock jewelry from other talented Colorado artists.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Contemporary Aesthetic: Ideal for the modern couple looking for sleek, contemporary designs in Denver.

• Artistic Flair: Each engagement ring is crafted as a unique work of art, showcasing exquisite craftsmanship and attention to detail.

• Woman-Owned: Proudly woman-owned and operated, offering a personalized touch and commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

Website: Balefire Goods

Back to Top

Sarah O. Jewelry

Sarah O. Jewelry, founded by Sarah Ortega, has become a beloved name in Denver's jewelry scene. As a woman and Latina-owned business, Sarah's background in fashion and design led her to create delicate, detailed pieces that are both timeless and trendy. Her boutique offers a warm, inviting atmosphere where every customer feels at home.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Intricate Designs: Explore beautifully detailed and meticulously crafted engagement rings.

• Ethical Practices: Commitment to conflict-free stones and sustainable materials, ensuring your ring is as ethical as it is stunning.

• Warm Atmosphere: Their boutique feels like a cozy haven, providing a personalized and welcoming experience.

Website: Sarah O. Jewelry

Back to Top

Kate Maller Jewelry

Kate Maller Jewelry combines rustic charm with modern elegance. Kate, an architect-turned-jeweler, started her brand with a vision to create pieces that reflect the natural beauty of Colorado. Her designs use ethically sourced materials and are crafted with an eye for detail and sustainability.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Natural Elegance: Discover designs that blend nature and sophistication, perfect for the eco-conscious couple.

• Sustainable Practices: Ethically sourced and eco-friendly materials ensure your ring is as beautiful as it is ethical.

• Handcrafted Beauty: Each ring is a unique masterpiece, meticulously handcrafted to perfection.

Website: Kate Maller Jewelry

Back to Top

Fout Jewelry Design

Fout Jewelry Design, led by David Fout, offers a truly bespoke experience for couples looking for unique engagement rings. David's journey into jewelry design started with his background in metalworking and a passion for creating personalized pieces. Each ring is crafted with care and precision, ensuring it perfectly reflects your love story.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Custom Creations: Discover completely bespoke designs tailored to your unique vision and style.

• Attention to Detail: Experience high-quality craftsmanship and meticulous design, ensuring every detail is perfect.

• Personalized Service: Work directly with the designer to create your dream ring, receiving personalized attention and expert guidance.

Website: Fout Jewelry Design

Back to Top

Todd Reed

Todd Reed is synonymous with luxury and innovation. Hand-forged in Boulder, Colorado, Todd's bold designs and unconventional materials make his rings stand out. If you're looking for a statement piece that reflects your unique love story, Todd Reed is your go-to.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Innovative Designs: Explore designs that push the boundaries of traditional jewelry, perfect for those seeking something unique.

• Sustainable Practices: Commitment to ethical sourcing and sustainability, ensuring your ring is both beautiful and eco-friendly.

• Handcrafted Excellence: Each piece is meticulously hand-forged in Boulder, showcasing exquisite craftsmanship and attention to detail.

Website: Todd Reed

Back to Top

CLP Jewelry

CLP Jewelry, created by Christy Lea Payne, offers unique, handcrafted pieces that blend rustic charm with a touch of elegance. Christy's love for well-worn and well-loved pieces began in her dad’s barn in Norman, Oklahoma. Inspired by her travels and life's perfect imperfections, Christy and her all-female metalsmith crew create designs that are as distinctive as they are beautiful.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Rustic Elegance: Discover designs that combine sophistication with a touch of edge, perfect for those who appreciate unique style.

• Unique Creations: No two pieces are exactly the same, ensuring your ring is as unique as your love story.

• Personal Touch: Each piece is a reflection of Christy's artistic vision and travels, offering a personalized touch and unique craftsmanship.

Website: CLP Jewelry

Back to Top

Metalmark Fine Jewelry

Metalmark Fine Jewelry, founded by best friends Samantha Larkins and Mary Leppert, blends luxury with a personal touch. Their boutique offers a curated selection of high-quality engagement rings designed to be cherished for a lifetime. Their commitment to excellence and personalized service makes every visit special.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Luxury Designs: Explore elegant and sophisticated pieces that are timeless, on-trend, and completely unique.

• High-Quality Materials: Only the best materials for your special day, ensuring lasting beauty and durability.

• Personal Service: Enjoy a boutique experience with personalized attention and expert guidance.

Website: Metalmark Fine Jewelry

Back to Top

J. Mancarella Jewelry

J. Mancarella Jewelry, founded by John ManCarella, stands out for its commitment to ethical practices and inclusive design. John, a transgender artist and master jeweler, aims to create jewelry everyone can enjoy wearing, regardless of their identity. Each piece is handmade with 100% recycled precious metals and prioritizes ethically sourced gemstones and upcycled diamonds.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Inclusive Design: Discover jewelry designed to be enjoyed by everyone, embracing diversity and individuality.

• Ethical and Sustainable: Commitment to using recycled precious metals and ethically sourced gemstones, ensuring your jewelry is both beautiful and eco-friendly.

• Beautiful Craftsmanship: Each piece is meticulously crafted to showcase the natural beauty of the gemstones, reflecting exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail.

Website: Mancarella Jewelry

Back to Top

Thollot & Co

Thollot Diamonds, founded by Troy and Joy Thollot, is a testament to love, passion, and dedication in the jewelry business. Their journey began in 1987 when Troy, at the age of 18, started working at a jewelry store where he met Joy, the jeweler of the store. What started as taking out the trash and cleaning up the bench turned into a lifelong love for the jewelry business and each other. Troy and Joy, both GIA Graduate Gemologists, gained experience across various jewelry stores before settling in Colorado.

Why Choose This Local Colorado Jeweler:

• Family-Owned: Founded and run by Troy and Joy Thollot, with a legacy passed down to their daughters, offering a personalized touch and commitment to quality.

• Community Focus: Dedicated to serving the Thornton community with custom designs and name-brand jewelry, supporting local clients with personalized service.

• Recognition and Awards: Named one of America's Top Two Coolest Stores by InStore Magazine in 2020, showcasing their commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction.

Website: Thollot & Co

Back to Top

Stone Selection

Choosing the right stone for your engagement or wedding ring is a big decision—it's the centerpiece that will capture attention and hold sentimental value. Let's explore your options:

Diamond’s and the 4 c’s

• Cut:

  • Determines the diamond's sparkle and shape. Popular cuts include:

    • Round Brilliant Cut:

      • Timeless Elegance: Known for its brilliance and sparkle, it's the most popular choice.

        • Advantages: Ideal for maximizing light return and brilliance.

    • Princess Cut:

      • Modern and Angular: Offers a contemporary look with excellent fire and brilliance.

        • Advantages: Looks larger than other shapes of the same carat weight.

    • Cushion Cut:

      • Soft and Romantic: Combines a square or rectangular shape with rounded corners.

        • Advantages: Provides a vintage feel with a modern twist.

    • Emerald Cut:

      • Elegant and Sophisticated: Known for its step cuts and large, open table.

        • Advantages: Offers a unique look with a hall-of-mirrors effect.

• Color:

  • Diamonds are graded on a color scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown). Colorless diamonds (D-F) are rare and valuable.

• Clarity:

  • Refers to the presence of imperfections or inclusions within the diamond. Clarity grades range from Flawless (FL) to Included (I).

• Carat Weight:

  • Indicates the diamond's size. Larger diamonds are generally more expensive.

Colored Gemstones

Just a few of the gemstone options you could go with! Some popular options are gemstones that match your partners birthstone, or any type of energy your partner reasonates with. Each gemstone has unique characteristics, durability, and care requirements. Choose one that matches your lifestyle and aesthetic preferences.

• Sapphire:

  • Royal Blue Beauty: Symbolizes loyalty and trust, perfect for a timeless and classic look.

    • Advantages: Durable and available in various shades, including peach, pink, and yellow.

• Ruby:

  • Passionate Red: Represents love and passion, making it a meaningful choice for an engagement ring.

    • Advantages: Hard and durable, ideal for everyday wear.

• Emerald:

  • Rich Green Hues: Symbolizes growth, fertility, and rebirth, making it a unique choice for an engagement ring.

    • Advantages: Offers a regal look with excellent clarity and transparency.

• Morganite:

  • Soft Pink Tones: Known for its romantic and delicate color, perfect for a feminine and elegant look.

    • Advantages: Affordably priced and complements a variety of skin tones.

• Moissanite:

  • Brilliant Sparkle: Offers exceptional brilliance and fire, similar to diamonds.

    • Advantages: More affordable than diamonds and eco-friendly.

• Opal:

  • Playful and Colorful: Features a unique play-of-color that varies with each stone.

    • Advantages: Offers a one-of-a-kind look with a rainbow of hues.

Back to Top

Engagement Ring Style and Design

Choosing the perfect style and design for your engagement or wedding ring is such an important decision—it’s a piece that will symbolize your love and commitment. Let me walk you through the options available:

Ring Styles

• Solitaire Engagement Rings:

  • Classic and Timeless: These rings feature a single, stunning center stone that really shines.

  • Popular Variations

    • Round,

    • Princess-cut

    • Oval solitaire rings

• Halo Engagement Rings:

  • Enhanced Brilliance: A central diamond or gemstone surrounded by a halo of smaller stones for a dazzling effect.

  • Popular Variations:

    • Cushion-cut

    • Round-cut

    • Pear-shaped halo rings

• Vintage Engagement Rings:

  • Romantic and Unique: Inspired by the intricate designs of the past, these rings are full of character.

  • Popular Variations:

    • Art Deco

    • Victorian

    • Edwardian styles

• Modern/Contemporary Engagement Rings:

  • Sleek and Minimalist: Clean lines and geometric shapes give these rings a modern edge.

  • Popular Variations:

    • Bezel-set designs

    • Tension-set rings

    • Asymmetrical styles

• Three-Stone Engagement Rings:

  • Symbolic and Elegant: With a center stone flanked by two smaller stones, these rings represent the past, present, and future.

  • Popular Variations:

    • Round-cut

    • Princess-cut

    • Emerald-cut three-stone rings

Metal Options

• Gold Engagement Rings:

  • Warm and Traditional: Gold rings come in

    • Yellow Gold: Classic and warm, suitable for traditional styles.

    • White Gold: Contemporary and sleek, often rhodium-plated to enhance brightness.

    • Rose Gold: Romantic and trendy, with a warm, pink hue.

  • Advantages: They’re hypoallergenic, durable, and timeless.

• Platinum Engagement Rings:

  • Naturally White and Durable: Platinum highlights the brilliance of diamonds and is incredibly resilient.

    • Advantages: It’s hypoallergenic, resistant to tarnishing, and perfect for everyday wear.

• Palladium Engagement Rings:

  • Lightweight and Modern: This metal is a cost-effective alternative to platinum.

    • Advantages: It’s hypoallergenic and has a similar appearance to platinum but is more affordable.

More info on How to Propose To Your Partner

Pin me for later!

More guides on engagements and proposals